Minimum standards and qualification required
Detailed scoring guidance
A. Team, Experience & Capability (25%)
• Relevance of experience
• Quality and relevance of example projects
• Skills and experience of key staff (including Welsh language capability in regard to arranging and conducting fieldwork in particular)
• Appropriateness of resourcing
• Confirmation that named staff will perform the work
B. Understanding of the Brief & Risk; Methodology, Approach & Delivery (45%)
• Understanding of water quality issues and nature-based solution
• Understanding of the Usk waterbody
• Understanding of Welsh Government position of water quality governance
• Understanding of nutrient markets and alternative forms of governance
• Identification of risks, constraints and sensitivities
• Understanding of statutory and procedural context
• Clear, logical and proportionate approach to each required output
• Project plan, milestones and deliverables
• Approach to evidence, data, mapping and uncertainty
• Quality assurance and review arrangements
• Realism and deliverability of timetable
C. Project Management & Governance (10%)
• Clarity of management and governance arrangements
• Communication and reporting approach
• Risk management
• Responsiveness and flexibility
• Arrangements for liaison with BBNPA
• Evidence that the bidder complies with UK employment law, ensures staff assigned to the contract are competent, supported, and supervised, and demonstrates inclusive practices with reasonable adjustments under the Equality Act 2010
D. Cost & Added Value (20%)
• Value for money (not just lowest price)
• Transparency and clarity of cost breakdown
• Realism of staff inputs and rates
• Clarity of expenses and assumptions
• Any genuine added value
|